An enquiring mind
Ken Garland: Structure and SubstanceBiographical essay by Adrian Shaughnessy
Edited by Tony Brook and Adrian Shaughnessy
Designed by Spin
Unit Editions, £35
Ken Garland (b. 1929) is something of an enigma in British graphic design. Not fitting comfortably into any category, he has been a successful commercial practitioner, a proselytiser for responsible, socially aware design, a teacher and a critic (see Reputations, Eye 66). He wears many hats. He is still an energetic self-publisher and a popular lecturer, in part because of his individualistic stance on issues such as protest and activism that resonate with today’s design students.
Arguably, Adrian Shaughnessy is well placed to unravel the enigma and to demonstrate Garland’s contribution to British graphic design. His earlier book on starting out in the design business (How to Be a Graphic Designer Without Losing Your Soul reviewed in Eye 58) addresses the conflicts that practising designers encounter along the way. Garland’s life and work has been, it seems to me, a master class in trying to resolve some of those conflicts, in particular how to be influential without seeking acclaim.
The book’s subtitle, ‘Structure and Substance’, which derives from an essay by Garland, captures something of his philosophy but also applies to the biography itself. Shaughnessy has dissected his subject piece by piece, reviewing his work as a designer, writer, photographer and teacher, discussing his ethics and politics, which are critical of our predominantly consumer-focused society, as well as his creative output. The extensive illustrated section covers the ground visually: graphic work, logos, photography and images of Garland’s studio.
A picture emerges of a man who has ploughed his own furrow quietly and consistently: his politics, wit and intelligence clearly visible. Working from the same home in north London for most of his career, Garland finds work and life inseparable. They inform each other. As Shaughnessy neatly puts it: ‘This fusion of the quotidian and the ideological explains why Garland remains a heroic figure amongst designers.’
One aspect of Garland’s influence is his observations, not only on clients but also on the craft of design. His Graphics Handbook of 1966 lists among the tools of a designer’s trade now long-forgotten type scales and ruling pens – but also the telephone. This was an arresting thought at the time – obvious but curiously prescient. Garland realised that without communication skills, designers would never get very far in understanding their clients and winning their trust.
Enquiring, writing and talking are a natural part of the design process. Given its relevance to the author’s thesis that Garland is not easily pigeonholed, I feel Shaughnessy might have usefully included more extracts from Garland’s writing to expand on this thought.
The book is pleasure to handle: a usable format, not so oversized as to be fit only for the coffee table. It is clearly sectioned, but I wonder whether a more tightly edited selection of work, rather than what appears to be a catalogue raisonné, from his student notebooks to his recently self-published photography books, would have enhanced Garland’s reputation further. Perhaps the apparent unevenness of some of the graphic work is all part of the practical philosophy. It is not about style, about ‘look how clever I am’, nor getting in the way of the client’s objective. Garland knows his place in relationship to his clients (his ‘partners’).
For most readers the works that will stand out are the black-and-white photos from the 1960s, and the early graphics for Design magazine, CND (the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament) and Galt Toys. From the distance of half a century, these appear fresh and surprisingly contemporary. (I remember having a copy of the CND Aldermaston March poster on my bedroom wall back in the 1960s. It stood out then; it does now.)
With this book, Ken Garland’s work rightly becomes part of the canon of twentieth-century British graphic design. Only the enigma of his funny hats remains.
The text-free cover of Ken Garland shows its subject (right) with Peter Cole (centre) and Colin Bailey in 1982.
Top: spread showing work for Dancer & Hearne Bros, designed by Ken Garland and Associates, 1962-64.
Eye is the world’s most beautiful and collectable graphic design journal, published quarterly for professional designers, students and anyone interested in critical, informed writing about graphic design and visual culture. It is available from all good design bookshops and online at the Eye shop, where you can buy subscriptions, back issues and single copies of the latest issue. You can see what Eye 85 looks like at Eye before You Buy on Vimeo.